I’ve not been doing a good job reviewing books that I’ve
read so I decided to chat up some with “mini-reviews” of several books that I’ve
enjoyed this summer. I still need to
finish up with at least one more post on my nine days in NYC and hopefully
write about a few more things going on in my life other than drowning in sweat
after having finished mowing the lawn.
Anyway, here are mini reviews of a few of the books I’ve been reading
this summer:
Pat Conroy, South of
Broad (2009). I listened to this
book on Audible, which is a task as it is quite long and there were sections
that I went back and listened to a second time.
It is the story of Leo King and his friends, who were all thrown
together during desegregation in Charleston in the late 1960s. When we meet Leo, we realize he is a fragile
high school student who will be a senior.
His older brother has committed suicide, which has haunted Leo (and we
don’t learn of the reason until late in the book). The first part of the book tells about the
meeting up of this group of friends that include people from the Charleston
gentry to African-Americans, to orphans and poor-abused whites (Sheba becomes a
movie star and Trevor a musician and both are haunted by an estranged father
that keeps in the shadows). The second
part of the book is 20 years in the future, where the movie star comes back to
Charleston to seek the help of her friends to find her gay brother who has
disappeared. They all head to San
Francisco and find Shela’s brother who is dying of AIDS and bring him back to
Charleston. The book then jumps back to
1969 and high school football, before jumping back to the present in Charleston
with Sheba and Trevor’s crazy father and a city that endures the fury of
Hurricane Hugo. This book deals with a lot of sensitive
topics: child abuse, ecclesiastical abuse (by a priest), the struggle with race
and class in the American South, AIDS, and local issues like Hugo’s
destruction. Like all his writings,
Conroy gives us wonderful descriptions of South Carolina’s Low Country while
weaving wonderful stories.
Arthur Herman, How the
Scots Invented the Modern World (New York: Broadway Books, 2001), 474
pages. My daughter gave me this book for
Father’s Day… Although skeptical at
first, thinking that since it came out a few years after “How the Irish Save
Civilization,” those of us with Scottish blood and hubris would naturally think
we’d have a hand in creating civilization.
The book rose above hubris, showing how Scotland rose above the warlord
era of the Clans to become a modern nation and then (mainly through immigration
and education), shared such a vision with the rest of the world. A lot of this book goes into politics,
especially around the Jacobite rebellion in 1845, an attempt to place a Stuart
(Bonnie Prince Charles) back on the throne for Great Britain. The attempt failed. Unlike a lot of mythology that shows the era
of the clans (the chiefs were essentially warlords) to be glamorous, Herman dispels
this myth and also dispels the idea that all the Highland Clans supported the
Jacobite efforts (the MacKenzies, my main clan, were divided). Instead of this being a Scottish rebellion, Herman
suggests it was more of a civil war.
After 1745, Scotland began to value education and attempted to provide
public schools for all children. The Scottish
Universities begin to rival Cambridge and Oxford and at times were even
better. The Scottish Enlightenment and
its aftermath were felt throughout the Western world (David Humes, Thomas
Hobbes, Adam Smith, Thomas Reid, etc).
Although I would have liked to have seen more treatment of Scottish
Common Sense Philosophy, Herman does admit its influence into the Declaration
of Independence. Another area in which the Scots excelled was trade and
Scottish companies were the leaders in fostering trade throughout the British Empire
and around the globe. After discussing
the Scottish Enlightenment, the growth of Scottish Industry (for a century, Glasgow
led the world in tonnage of ships built) and trade, he discussed the role
various Scots played around the world.
He ends the book discussing the economic downturn in Scotland as
industries moved elsewhere and what its future might be. Herman also discusses the rise of Scottish
pride (thanks to the pens of folks like Sir. Walter Scott) and how the how “tartan”
thing became accepted and reinterpreted in Scotland and throughout the
world. Although the book was written
more than a decade before the Scottish failed vote for independence, Herman
makes the case that Scotland has long been tied to Great Britain and would
suffer if such ties were severed.
William Zissner, editor, Extraordinary
Lives; The Art and Craft of American Biography (New York: American
Heritage, 1985), 252 pages. Zissner,
best known for his book On Writing, has
been a favorite author on writing for me.
He died a few months ago. Upon
his death, I decided to see what I haven’t yet read of his and came across this
book which he edited. In the mid-80s, he
brought together six major biographers to lecture on their craft at the New
York City library. Zissner edited the
lectures and wrote the introductory chapter and published this book. What excites me about this book is that I
have read extensively the work of two of the biographers (David McCullough, and
Robert Caro). At the time of the
lecture, they both had done a major work and was working on others, but they
were still new at their craft. McCollough
had not yet published his major work on John Adams (he had published his work on Theodore Roosevelt and was working on his
biography of Harry Truman) and Caro had just published his first book on Lyndon
Johnson’s early life (he has since published three more and hasn’t yet gotten to
Johnson’s presidency). Other biographers included are Paul Nagel (The
Adam’s women), Richard Sewall (Emily Dickerson), Ronald Steel (Walter Lippmann),
and Jean Strouse (J. Pierpont Morgan and the family of Harry and Henry James). There is some good stuff in this old book,
especially if one is considering the task of writing a biography.
Quote: "In fact, the coexistence of these two biographies (Morris' and McCullough's biographies on T. Roosevelt) illustrate an important point, which is that there is not just one true story about any of these lives; there are instead versions of the past..." (Strouse, p. 166)